Saturday, December 1, 2012

That pesky clearance problem

I have received quite a few questions over the last year or two about wing clearance during takeoff in pterosaurs.  This seems to be a sticking point for some, as evidenced by the problem rearing it's ugly head again with the recent Chatterjee et al. GSA conference spectacular (see earlier posts below).  It would seem prudent to lay out some of the issues surrounding this problem - or, more specifically, to explain why this isn't really such a huge problem after all.

Because of the way that flying animals scale, larger, long-winged species with greater flight speeds flap with lower amplitudes than smaller species (on average, that is).  Interestingly enough, this means that the amount of clearance required by large flyers is comparatively small, so long as they can get up a good bit of speed on takeoff.  To examine this issue more closely and quantitatively for giant pterosaurs, we can look at something call the Strouhal number.

Strouhal Number is a dimensionless parameter that describes the "gait" of a flapping flyer (or really, anything that is oscillating its propulsion system in a fluid).  As it turns out, because of vortex shedding efficiency constraints, animals are remarkably constrained with regards to their Str during cruising flight: it only varies from about 0.2 to 0.4 including everything from insects to large birds.  There is a great explanation of this number, and its application to flying animals, here (I've shared that link elsewhere to good effect).

Str for a flapping flyer can be calculated as the ratio of flapping amplitude to the product of frequency and velocity.  The largest pterosaurs probably flapped at a rate just over 1 hertz in cruising flight, and likely had minimum steady state speeds near 12 m/s and a cruising speed a good bit greater, say around 20 m/s or more. 

Now, during launch, the animal probably only gets up near steady state stall speed (incidentally, it doesn't have to, contrary to what you often read in basic biology textbooks), and the Str can rise above the 0.4 mark that we might expect during cruising.  Let's let the Str rise to 0.50 and constrain the launch velocity to the min steady state stall speed above.  That still gives us an amplitude for the very tip of the wing in Quetzalcoatlus of 5.6 meters.  Of that total arc, about 40% of it is upstroke, so that leaves a required glenoid height at the end of the launch phase of 3.4 meters or so.  Given that Quetzalcoatlus had a glenoid height of about 2.5 meters while standing, it turns out that very little leaping is required at all for sufficient clearance (less than 1 meter).  The animal still needs to jump, but nothing extraordinary is required.


7 comments:

  1. You may have fancy quantified calculations, but I find your hypotheses difficult to believe without a discussion of pushups and pogo sticks. http://pterosaurheresies.wordpress.com/2012/11/12/quetzalcoatlus-forelimb-leap-questioned-by-chatterjee-et-al-2012/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sigh, thanks for the note Mickey. I finally decided to say something on his blog, and just posted an extended comment. It's waiting for moderation. Hoping he'll post it.

    You know what, though: even with the pogo sticks, biomechanical mistakes, bad data (yes, large bats do launch quadrupedally), etc, Dave's launch model is still better than the Chatterjee one.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Leaving aside the madness to concentrate on actual reality, there;s also the issue of the wings striking the ground. I know Mike knows this well (indeed we were chatting about it the other day), but not all readers may - it's far from uncommmon for wings to strike the ground during take-off for both birds and bats.

    So while Mike's point is a good one (Q. probably only needs to be up about 1 m from standing to avoid hitting the ground), I strongly suspect that pterosaurs in general could take a bit of strike when taking off, so it's plausible that they could take off without full clearance and simply take a bit of a battering to the wingtip for the first couple of flight strokes that would give it clearance. They may not have needed to jump at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great point Dave; indeed we did talk about this just a few days ago. As an extreme example, check this out: http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0032074?imageURI=info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0032074.g001

      That is a figure from a PLOS ONE paper showing a bat (Myotis) not merely striking the ground with the wing tips, but actually using them to push off during the launch! The distal wing phalanx flexes substantially during the maneuver, and while no force plate data are available for that study, each wing tip must be taking more than a body weight apiece.

      Delete
  4. No words can express, no act of gratitude can relay, no gift can represent what your love and support have meant to me. Please accept this note as an indicator of my heartfelt appreciation for everything you are.
    agen poker online
    bandar poker online
    agen bandar qq

    ReplyDelete
  5. Haloo, Kami Dari SenyumQQ ingin mengajak kalian para pecinta poker online indonesia.
    Sebagai server yang terbaik, tercepat dan terpercaya SenyumQQ berhasil menduduki penghargaan 5 situs terbesar di indonesia.
    Dengan tampilan awal yang menarik juga mendukung situs kami ramai di kunjungi oleh sebagian besar Indonesia.
    Dengan penawaran yang kami ajukan paling terbaik di antara situs judi online di seluruh indonesia

    • BONUS DOUBLE CASHBACK •

    Bonus double cashback yang kami berikan adalah tujuan kami untuk membuat para pemain yang bermain di SenyumQQ, karena para player tidak perlu menunggu pembagian Turnover 1x dalam 1 minggu, hanya di SenyumQQ kalian bisa merasakan pembagian Turnover 2x dalam 1 minggu, dengan pembagian 0.5% di setiap hari rabu & sabtu.

    • BONUS REFERRAL •

    Bonus referral yang di bagikan sebesar 20%, yang di bagikan secara otomatis tanpa syarat dan ketentuan.
    Bonus referral yang kami berikan dengan persenan terbesar di indonesia mampu mengangkat para pemain untuk mengajak teman teman nya bermain di SenyumQQ, semakin banyak teman yang di ajak bermain di situs kami, semakin banyak juga Bonus yang di dapatkan :)

    SENYUMQQ.COM AGEN JUDI BANDAR KIU ONLINE INDONESIA TERBAIK DAN TERPERCAYA
    WWW.SENYUMQQ.COM
    Keuntungan yang di dapatkan bermain di SenyumQQ :
    - Minimal Depo & Wd hanya Rp.15.000,-
    - Didukung 5 Bank Besar Indonesia (BNI BRI BCA DANAMON & MANDIRI)
    - Bonus Referral 20% Seumur Hidup!!
    - Pelayanan dari CS Ramah & Profesional 24jam/7hari
    SenyumQQ juga menyediakan 6 Game Seperti :
    - Poker
    - DominoQQ
    - Capsa Susun
    - Adu Q
    - Bandar Q
    - Bandar Poker
    - Sakong (New)
    - Bandar66 (New Game)
    Dengan Pelayanan Dari CS ( Customer Service ) Yang Ramah, dan Professional 24 Jam Nonstop Melayani Anda :)
    Info Lebih Lanjut Silahkan Hubungi LiveChat kami Atau
    CONTACT :
    BB : D1CD3A22
    Tel / Sms / Whatsapp : +855.155.90751

    ReplyDelete